Showing posts with label DHC7B. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DHC7B. Show all posts

Friday, February 27, 2015

10 Games, 10 Times: Iron Ivan's Disposable Heroes / Coffin for Seven Brothers

Soviets try to get their tanks across the table in a later game in the series.
i had played DH/C7B a handful of times before, initially not really digging it, but later coming to decide that it might well be my favorite set or 1:1 WWII gaming, for squad to a platoon per side. Yet, I hardly played it thereafter, and when i did, it was primarily infantry only conflicts, hence its inclusion on my 10 Games, 10 times challenge list.  



The first few games were straight up infantry affairs to help me shake off the cobwebs and figure out where I was forgetting rules.
Backing up, for those who don't know, DH/C7B is a 1:1 set of WWII skirmish rules, where the basic unit is the fire team. It's recommended for up to a platoon per side, with support, although you can extend it further if you have time or multiple players.

My sole gripe with the rules is the use of markers for tracking activation, pinned, acquisition status (for armor), and # of armor penetration hits. You also need some way of tracking the number of destroyed units for each side, as these, plus the # of currently pinned units effect the initiative score.

So many markers. The white cards are blinds - I used Platoon Forward for many scenarios, along with its enemy force generation method. This is from one of the last games I played in the series - after I had mounted the figures to 3 inch squares.
However, so many games require markers, that it seems like short of an all or nothing approach to hits, or off table tracking (difficult in a 1 figure = 1 man game with more than a handful of figures per side), there really isn't a better option.

So, other than that, the game has a lot going for it although it took me 5 or so games to really see how good they were, as I kept forgetting rules in the early games or situations just didn't come up:
  • The Guts score - it effects both initiative and morale, including the ability to rally. It's a mix of quality and motivation.
  • simplified movement
    • if one figure reaches cover, the whole group does
    • move one figure, then place the rest around that figure, rather than measuring for all
    • terrain does not effect movement rates of infantry
    • Movement rate determines what additional actions a unit may perform and any penalties
  • Snap (opportunity) fire is restricted to one enemy unit.
  • Using grenades to supplement a charge is abstracted and works quite smoothly
  • Taking fire, regardless of result, triggers a Guts check - this seems right to me, but surprisingly few systems I have played incorporate it
  • It is difficult to score a hit on a target in cover - based on what i've read about the expenditure of ammo in WWII to hit a target, this too seems right to me.
  • The way it handles armor.
I wanted to really go big,both because i wanted to see if it made a big difference in my enjoyment, and also as a way to see if I could at some point eliminate a table and the space it takes up. Playing on the floor was loads of fun but no more so than a table, as it turns out.

One thing that has flummoxed me about some other systems at the 1:1 scale has been armor: either they are too simple, and the type of vehicle does not matter, or too complex to the point of having to use calculus to understand the tables. DH/C7B's system for attacks by and against armor sits somewhere in the middle and I rather like it. It has enough flavor to get a feel for the period and the differences in equipment, but not so complicated that every rivet matters.

I had to fudge any vehicle that wasn't a tank, since no stats are included in the core rules beyond a vehicle or two per army.
One  downside is the mix of roll low/roll high is somewhat annoying - you want to roll low always -to acquire a target, to hit, to pass a Guts check, but  when you're rolling for armor penetration, then you want to roll high. 

It's hard to see, but the PZ. IV had just made it onto the table when one of the T-34s brewed it up on a single hit This is less frequent an occurrence than my pictures might relate.
The other is that the core rules, which contain the "big four" nations, do not include much in the way of vehicles for these. As such, I had to fudge a bit on anything not remotely covered. The force supplements contain the desired data but those are additional purchases.

The core rules do, however, cover tank riders!
Once again, the 10 Games, 10 Times Challenge comes through, and I have a new understanding and appreciation for this game. That said, I also have come to realize, that i prefer 1:1 games with 3-5 figures, rather than squad to platoon sized engagements. 

As a bonus, I suspect these rules could work well for that - treating each figure as their own fire team and disregarding the man-alone rule and the "only 1/2 figures per unit can shoot" rule. I may try them in that respect at some later date, but Five Men in Normandy awaits first.



Monday, July 7, 2014

An Idea for Soloing DHC7B to Preserve Initiative

Playing Nuts! (Two Hour Wargames) lately, and my own Featherstone's Nuts, has got me thinking about solitaire Disposable Heroes: Coffin for Seven Brothers (Iron Ivan). Like most ideas, this one came to me in the shower.

Although I was thinking specifically about DHC7B, this method would work for any game where the sides roll for initiative and the winner can choose to go first or second.

In the past, I've tended to either change the rule such that the winner always goes first, or replace the initiative mechanism with a card based one, by unit. The problem with the former is that it doesn't give the winner the opportunity to take a reactive posture, whereas the latter is that it doesn't as easily account for relative leadership ratings (although it can).

Stealing from the Solo DBA rules, we can assign to the Non-Player Commander a rating of Cautious, Neutral, or Aggressive. It might seem easiest to say a Cautious commander always goes second, a Neutral commander 50/50 and an Aggressive commander always goes first.

Except, that doesn't quite feel right - surely there are circumstances when a Cautious leader still wants to move first, and situations where an Aggressive leader might prefer to react.

Better might be:

  • Cautious: First - 25%, Second - 75%
  • Neutral: 50/50
  • Aggressive: First - 75%, Second - 25%

Since DHC7B uses d10, I'll go with:

  • Cautious: First - 20%, Second - 80%
  • Neutral: 50/50
  • Aggressive: First - 80%, Second - 20%

The second issue is that activation in DHC7B alternates between sides until all units are activated. 

Previously, I replaced the initiative mechanism with an activation deck to determine which unit went next. Besides ignoring leadership factors, it meant that one side might have a run of several units in a row moving. There's nothing wrong with that from my perspective, but if I want to play closer to the designers' ideas, then that won't do. 

What I can do, whether utilizing the method above or not for initiative, is give each SIDE its own deck. Thus, the choice of which particular unit goes when is equally random for both sides (that is, it doesn't favor the solo player) and still allows me to use the intended initiative mechanism.

Saturday, August 17, 2013

WWII PTO : Defend Against a Raid

Watching Ken Burns's The War has been giving me the itch to play more wargames and I had some time Friday night, so I grabbed my old cloth, threw it over the table and then randomly generated the terrain using the rules from War Against Japan.

For the actual game I used Disposable Heroes & Coffin for Seven Brothers, but I've been thinking part of the problem with any platoon sized game at 1:1 is moving the figures can take up precious game time. 

The obvious answer was multi-figure bases. So I used some cheap DIY movement "trays" (craft foam glued to cereal box) with 2 figures to a base. 

Voila, 1/2 as much to move!

For my force, I decided to use the Early War Marines (as detailed in Red Sun, Red Death) - treating the game as taking place in '42.

The scenario I rolled was Defend Against a Raid and was generated using Platoon Forward. The Japanese were on the attack and my Marines were dug in and defending an observation post. Only 1 squad would be on the board with a 2nd squad available as reinforcements.

The Japanese were to capture a prisoner. Odd, I though, given the "no quarter given" nature of the Pacific, but, OK. 

Tactical decisions for the Japanese were handled by Platoon Forward's "All Knowing Odds Table" which is like a simpler version of Mythic GME using just 1d10 and no Chaos factor.

Since I use a card activation instead of the rules-as-written initiative for DHC7B, as suggested by Platoon Forward I added an event card (when drawn, roll a d6, 6=event, then roll on appropriate tables in Platoon Forward).

The setup:
My squad set up on the hill, per the scenario description. 

My BAR team is top most, sarge and the rifle team is in the foreground. 

The Japanese started out represented by four Type A blinds (infantry) and 1 Type B (support weapons). They would not be revealed until they shot,  even if they moved  into the open.



The Game:

There wasn't much (any) movement on my part, save for being forced to Fall Back and then advancing to the original position. 

During turn 1, four A blinds were revealed, two were nothing, one was an LMG team, and one was this:


an entire squad plus their platoon commander.

In Turn 2, the B blind turned out to be an HMG team and the Japanese began their attempted assault on my position.


[here the pictures stop. They were breaking my flow and I was really getting into the game]

The LMG and HMG did a number on my squad but we still managed to force the Japanese to fall back.

Multiple times I contemplated getting my squad off the table and conceding the game to the Japanese, especially since my reinforcements seemed to be AWOL.

But the dice gods decided to grant me some favor and, suddenly, I was cutting down the Japanese, nearly entirely eliminating that once imposing full squad. 

So each turn, I'd tell myself, "just one more and then we'll fall back if the reinforcements don't show."  I wanted my men to put up a good fight, but I didn't want to see them massacred. Even if this wasn't a campaign game, I didn't want to lead them total destruction.

But I got greedy. I wanted to win, not just escape.

Their HMG and LMG managed to eliminate Sarge and the rifle team and then, to my surprise, the LMG team decided to advance, with the HMG providing covering fire and pins.

Activation went their way for several turns in a row and the Japanese charged into close combat, at which point it was clear that the dice gods had decided to abandon me.

Outnumbered 4 to 3 (the bar team suffered a wound back in Turn 1), I thought I had a chance still. Especially when, after the Japanese finished their portion of the round of melee, I only suffered 1 loss. My attacks missed their mark entirely though, and on the Japanese 2nd attempt, they scored 3 wounds. 

I counted this as taking 3 prisoners. It took 9 turns, but they achieved their objective and won the game and I spent the rest of the evening replaying the game in my head.

I should have gotten those boys out of there. I should have learned the rules for artillery fire and taken advantage of the fact that the odds were high that i'd have arty support. 

But I was lazy, and then I got caught up in the thrill of combat, and those boys paid for it.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Russian Tank Escort with Disposable Heroes/Coffin for Seven Brothers

Citizen, behold a squad of our mighty soldiers escorting a fine example of Soviet modern engineering and made by your own Proletariat hands.

Small dice indicate possible enemy forces to be drawn from a card deck. Mythic would determine whether or not an enemy force revealed itself on any given turn.

See how your brave comrades advance fearlessly despite the threat of the nefarious Barbarians of Fascism!


Even under fire from the German machine guns, the brave children of Mother Russia hold firm and deliver a devastating volley.

Like rot in the grain stores, the Nazi-snake takes much effort to flush out! But the effort was made with the greatest sacrifice of our Defenders of the Motherland!


Anti-tank fire erupts to the North, machine gun fire to the South East



The Germans have no anti-tank weapons left, and are unable to close with the well armored Soviet workhorse.

*****
Rules used: Disposable Heroes/Coffin for Seven Brothers (with card draw activation)
Forces:
Russia - 1 T-34, 1 Rifle Squad (2 sections, one of Sergeant + 5 Privates, and 1 LMG section with Corporal, gunner and Private with Rifle).
German - A deck of 10 cards was set up, 3 of which were blank. The remainder varied from LMG team, panzerfaust team, up to a rifle section.
Scenario objective:  Russians (me) - Escort the tank off the opposite corner. Germans - stop them.

Although the Russian T-34 made it off the table, they lost 9 men to the German 6. So, a victory but another Pyrrhic one at that.

This was primarily to test the feasibility of using a single squad with DHC7B. I found it worked much better than I thought. The idea came about as I considered experimenting with G.A.S.L.I.G.H.T. for WWII.

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Save a Dead Tree: Iron Ivan's Disposable Heroes

In January, I decided that one of the things I'd do this year is to take a look at those books on my shelves that I hadn't read or used in any significant way and do just that (and after my recent inventory of just how many books that is, I feel particularly driven to do this). Recently, I've been doing that with Iron Ivan's Disposable Heroes/Coffin for Seven Brothers (DHC7B) and the Red Sun, Red Death (RSRD) supplement.

I picked up DHC7B up at Historicon 2009, based on many positive reviews, but it has sat on my bookshelf ever since, used only occasionally for reference sake to answer questions about squad composition and weapons.

 I acquired the RSRD supplement in 2011(?) and it has seen even less use, if that's possible.  At least this book I explicitly purchased to serve as a reference.

If I'm honest, the reason for the lack of use initially was that I really didn't understand that, although it's 1:1, usually individually based,  and a skirmish type game, it isn't a game about individual figures. Which is what I was most interested in - at the time, anything more than a squad on the table seemed like a big commitment. 

I had one squad for any given nation, and that isn't really DHC7B's raison d'etre; it is a 1:1 game where the smallest maneuver element is the team, and the intended organizational unit fielded for a player is one platoon up to a company.

Fast forward to 2013 and I have ample numbers of figures to try the rules out. 

And try I did. 

What I liked:

  • Activation and actions by team does make it feel more like a trained unit and less like individual men running about.
  • Weapons are deadly if they hit.
  • the Guts check when receiving fire can pin the unit even if no figures are removed, aka suppression.
  • Multiple pins possible with increasingly worse effect.
  • Guts check for pin removal.
  • Easy to learn - after a few turns I pretty much had everything I needed to know memorized.
  • Grenades are abstract and easy to handle (I don't know why, but this is a stumbling block for me in a lot of rules) - they pin more often than they'll kill but that's the point I think.
  • Snap fire aka defensive fire, reaction fire, etc.
  • The rules encourage concentrating fire on any given unit, if possible, in order to score multiple pins.
  • Being caught in the open is a bad bad thing.
  • There are a lot of optional rules to pick and choose from.

What didn't I like:
  • Guts check for pin removal - if I understood it correctly, it uses the unmodified Guts value, which means it's really easy to remove a pin if your NCO/jr NCO is still with the team.
  • Actually hitting something in cover is extremely difficult. Thus, combined with easy pin removal, the  units stay on the table a long time even under fire. Hence why I believe the rules encourage concentration of fire. 
  • Modified Guts score takes into account the number of removed figures for a unit, which requires tracking in some way. Casualty figures would be useful for this.
  • Alternating IGO-UGO unit activation, and the unit to activate is player choice. This can likely be rectified by modifying activation to a card-based system, one card per unit, possibly with a Stop/ReShuffle card.
  • Aesthetically, I don't like d10s. Not a flaw in the game, just a personal preference.
  • A fire fight between two squads of USMC and 2 squads of Japanese, both sides in heavy cover, took nearly 2 hours. Even if you factor in the time spent looking things up here and there, that, to my mind, is a long time. Although that's fine if that's the kind of game I wanted, perhaps I'm too influenced by Two Hour Wargames, where the same fight would likely have lasted less than 10 minutes and involved a higher number of dead and wounded.
Despite the fact that there is a lot I like, and although some of the optional rules would address my dislikes - such as the use of any one "1" on a hit to take out the officer or special weapon - over all, I'm left feeling somewhat "meh" about the rules. I won't rule out giving them another chance, especially with optional rules and a card based activation sequence, but other rules, as it stands now, appeal to me more.

Nuts!, although not perfect, undoubtedly plays faster (although I'll try the same exact test scenario to be sure) and feels more chaotic during a fire fight. 

USE ME WWII, which gives much the same feel as DHC7B, might even be easier to learn, is far less money, and requires no theater specific supplement to get info for the Japanese - they're included in the rule book.